Every week of the nfl season includes some debatable roughing calls, or noncalls, and we had at least two in week 7 here in the nfc north. It sits on the data, a whole staff gets fired and an. Oct 02, 2018 it is a different rule that has thrown the nfl into chaos. The roughingthepasser calls that have roiled the nfl this season arent making the competition committee happy either, as several members of the committee are uncomfortable with the calls so far, according to judy battista of. Nfl tries to clarify roughing the passer rule, wont make changes. No matter what the nfl does, its officiating headaches. Lets take a closer look at how jameis winston became the mr. The nfls new roughing the passer body weight rule is a. All roughing the passer penalties that happened in the 2018 season, viewed by teams per game.
New nfl roughing the passer rule causing more problems. But check out how the nfl rule book addresses such a situation. Why the nfl rule book needs to be drastically simplified. The reaction to the increase in controversial penalties has been overwhelmingly negative, and the league has taken notice. Another thing that makes headlines is the leagues issue with the roughing the passer rule.
Sep 26, 2018 the roughingthepasser calls that have roiled the nfl this season arent making the competition committee happy either, as several members of the committee are uncomfortable with the calls so far, according to judy battista of nfl. Everything you need to know about the new nfl roughing. And, once again, packers linebacker clay matthews is smack dab in the middle of it all. Roughing the passer totals, by team 20092015 including. Sep 25, 2018 the rule in question rule 12, section 2, article 9b calls for a roughing the passer penalty when a defensive player lands on a passer with all or most of the defenders weight. Some nfl execs uncomfortable with roughingthepasser. The nfl added a new element to its roughing the passer rule this past offseason. Nfl says clay matthews hit was perfect example of roughing the passer. The rule, listed as rule 12, section 2, article 9b in the nfl rulebook. Is the leftwing roughingthepasser rule at risk of ruining the nfl. After being called for only four roughingthepasser penalties during.
The nfl rule book states the following, as it pertains to the quarterbacks knees. Sep 19, 2018 nfl says clay matthews hit was perfect example of roughing the passer. The nfls new roughing the passer rule is just plain silly. A rushing defender is prohibited from forcibly hitting in the knee area or below a. Competition committee uncomfortable with roughing calls. Joe thomas not happy with weak new roughing the passer calls. In gridiron football, roughing the passer is a foul in which a defensive player makes illegal. The nfl tweaked language in the rule book that emphasized penalizing defenders who use their body weight when they land on quarterbacks after making tackles, similar to a play that resulted in a. Clay matthews got hit with another roughing the passer call this week after landing on top of washingtons. There have been 34 roughing the passer penalties called through the first three weeks, compared to 16 through three games in 2017 and 20 in 2016.
Rule 12 in the nfl s 2018 rulebook details player conduct. The nfl competition committee met wednesday night via conference call to. The nfls new focus on roughing the passer has once again created a sunday evening ruckus. The first came in the second quarter of the detroit. All judgment calls, such as pass interference, holding and roughing the passer a play where a runner is ruled down by defensive contact, not involving a fumble the recovery of a. Cam newtons roughingthepasser complaints open pandoras. When jameis threw those interceptions he didnt do it for the fame, or the glory, or even because he couldnt see who he was throwing to. An exception to the roughing rule is where the passer rejoins a play after. Here is the applicable language straight out of the nfl s 2011 rule book. I get where both steratore and the rule book are coming from its definitely a call that can be debated based on what both say. The nfls sudden roughingthepasser obsession isnt about. Has the nfl gone too far with its new roughing the passer. Nov 01, 2016 cam newtons roughingthepasser complaints open pandoras box of questions.
Roughing will be called if, in the referees judgment, a pass rusher clearly should have known. After four roughing the passer calls in the steelers 3027 victory over the buccaneers monday night the most in an nfl game since 2001 pittsburgh quarterback ben roethlisberger noted. Some nfl execs uncomfortable with roughingthepasser penalties. Roughing the passer can also be called if the defender commits intimidating. Nfl officiating controversy wont go away the washington. This last sunday, roughing the passer penalties dropped to two from. Roughing the passer totals, by team 20092015 including homeaway splits submitted 3 years ago by saints daybreaker amount of roughing the passer calls each team has been the beneficiary of since 2009.
Eagles screwed by inconsistent enforcement of roughing the. Nfl faces backlash from defensive players over new roughing. Roughing the passer 2018 view by teams per game nfl. See 861cd for personal fouls prior to completion or interception. There were four rouhging the passer calls in monday nights game. One of the major themes of the 2018 nfl season, leaguewide, has been the enforcement of laughable roughing the passer calls, whether they be for accidental andor harmless contact with a. By much has been made this season about the changes to the roughing the passer rule that were instituted in the offseason by the nfl. Sep 25, 2018 dan patrick talks about the recent influx of roughing the passer penalties and how officials are being instructed to enforce the rule by the nfl. I think they called a similar one on the bears earlier, happened in the pats game a couple times and there were a few other examples i saw on redzone that they called it like that.
The nfl makes roughing the passer against the rules in an effort to protect its. For roughing the kicker or holder, loss of 15 yards from the. Sep 27, 2018 the nfl is getting roughed up over its amplified enforcement of roughingthepasser penalties that has generated headscratching calls and a seasonending injury to a defender trying to comply with the leagues mandate not to land fully on the quarterback. Sep 27, 2018 the nfl has issued a clarification on its muchdebated roughing the passer rule after three weeks of outrage from players, coaches and fans. Member clubs of the league may amend the rules from time to time, pursuant to the applicable voting procedures of the nfl constitution and bylaws. Oct 06, 2018 the nfl s new roughing the passer rule is silly new, 5 comments 2018 was supposed to include a silly rule that changed the game of football, but the wrong one showed up. What if nfl officials didnt call roughing the passer on.
Everyone really, really hates the nfls roughing the passer calls. A player of either team may block obstruct or impede an opponent at any time. Section 3 of the official playing rules of the national football league nfl rule book, is a foul under nfl rules and will be called by game officials. Members of the committee are unsure if anything will change with the rule emphasis or the way it is.
The new orleans saints, infamously hurt by a noncall in the nfc championship game, already have been involved in debates over two calls, and among other issues, a roughingthepasser penalty. It would be a 15yard penalty for roughing the passer. It is a different rule that has thrown the nfl into chaos. Several members of the committee, which made the rule a point of emphasis in the spring by pinpointing that they did not want defenders to land with their weight on. Defenders are allowed to contact a player attempting a forward pass while he still has. An away game at century link combined with an officiating crew that didnt pass a rule book around before the game led to a heartbreaking loss at the end of the day. The problem was that williamss weight landed on kessler and he was called for roughing the passer. Sep 25, 2018 the nfl s new roughingthepasser rule has been thrust into the spotlight after week 3 after miami dolphins defensive end william hayes suffered a seasonending injury trying to avoid the penalty. Sep 29, 2018 the nfl added a new element to its roughing the passer rule this past offseason. It can also be called if the player who tackles the passer makes helmet to. Welcome to the extra point, where members of the nfls football data and analytics team will share updates on leaguewide trends in football data, interesting visualizations that showcase innovative ways to use the leagues data, and provide an inside look at how the nfl uses datadriven insight to improve and monitor. Rule 12 player conduct section 1 blocking, use of hands, arms, and body legal and illegal block article 1 a player of either team may block obstruct or impede an. Aug 19, 2018 the new aaron rodgers rule or is it the anthony barr rule.
A defender continues an effort to tackle or hit a passer after the passer has already thrown a pass. The nfl backed the referee, of course, but surprisingly didnt fine matthews. The new orleans saints, infamously hurt by a noncall in the nfc championship game, have already been involved in debates over two calls, and among other issues, a. On thursday, pereira then published a list of qbs and the number of roughing the passer calls per 100 attempts, which showed vick close to the top and tony romo at the very bottom. Sep 27, 2018 the nfl backed the referee, of course, but surprisingly didnt fine matthews. Nfl says clay matthews hit was perfect example of roughing. Only quarterbacks with at least 40 games played are listed. The new orleans saints, infamously hurt by a noncall in the nfc championship game, have already been involved in debates over two calls, and among other issues, a roughing the passer penalty. The new aaron rodgers rule or is it the anthony barr rule.
I expect to see a ton of these calls this season pic. The nfl happens to know that his team was victimized for the most blown calls in the nfl. The new rule, which is located in rule 12, section 2, article 9 of the nfl s rule book, states a player will. The clay matthews roughing the passer penalty on sunday was a huge call and basically saved the vikings, who later tied it up and tied the game. A look at roughing the quarterback, broken down by the quarterback that benefited from the call. Cousins in a training video for teams regarding penalty calls. The nfls new roughing the passer rule is silly new, 5 comments 2018 was supposed to include a silly rule that changed the game of football, but the wrong one showed up. Focus on roughing the passer giving nfl a black eye wkty. A defensive player must not use his helmet against a. Roughing the passer and the nfls unfixable problem sports.
Is the leftwing roughingthepasser rule at risk of ruining. The nfls stupid new roughing the passer rule cost william hayes his season. The nfl has issued a clarification on its muchdebated roughing the passer rule after three weeks of outrage from players, coaches and fans. Roughing the passer calls like these have been weak compared to hits that havent been called.
Nfl clarifies roughing the passer rule to ensure consistency. No matter what the nfl does, its officiating headaches just. Oct 01, 2011 pereira then piled on, calling vicks complaint a bunch of bull, and said the eagles were notorious complainers about roughing the passer calls, be it with mcnabb or vick under center. The nfls controversial new roughing the passer rule, explained in a.
Oct 09, 2018 the packers offense has been one of the best aspects of the nfl for the last decade when rodgers plays. Roughing the passer and the nfls unfixable problem. The nfl is getting roughed up over its amplified enforcement of roughingthepasser penalties that has generated headscratching calls and a seasonending injury to a defender trying to comply with the leagues mandate not to land fully on the quarterback. Dan patrick on how the nfl can fix the roughing the passer. Clay matthews hit on alex smith is textbook roughing. I just hope that with all the ruckus being raised, that maybe something will be done by the competition committee, and perhaps flags will be called on actual roughing the passer calls, instead of every little hit that looks dangerous. The nfls new roughingthepasser rule has been thrust into the spotlight after week 3 after miami dolphins defensive end william hayes suffered a seasonending injury trying to avoid the penalty.
Sep 18, 2018 the clay matthews roughing the passer penalty on sunday was a huge call and basically saved the vikings, who later tied it up and tied the game. Ranting about roughing the passer penalties edgerocks. The nfls new roughing the passer body weight rule is a problem new, 9 comments myles garrett fell victim to the leagues rule, which doesnt account for important things like the laws. Sep 23, 2018 the nfl s new focus on roughing the passer has once again created a sunday evening ruckus. My favorite explanation of the new roughing the passer penalties came from new monday night football color commentator jason witten. Holding will be called if the defenders feet are taken away from him by the offensive. Roughing the passer totals, by team 20092015 including home.
Players, coaches and fans are criticizing the body weight rule that has resulted in some controversial roughing the passer penalties. Why the nfl rule book desperately needs to be simplified. The aaron rodgers rule is going to frustrate you while. Last week, talk about the nfls roughingthepasser call dominated the league, as flags were seemingly flying left and right. Highlight gerald mccoy called for roughing the passer. Here are the nfl rules on such a hit on a passer below the knees. Unlike virtually all other pages on the site where the number of games is team games this page does attempt to only count games in which the qb played, by way of looking to see if they were.
Because the act of passing often puts the quarterback or any other player attempting a pass in a position where he is particularly vulnerable to injury, special rules against roughing the passer apply. The roughing the passer calls that have roiled the nfl this season arent making the competition committee happy either. Aug 19, 2018 according to nfl official pete morelli, who explained the leagues rule changes to a group of twin cities media on thursday, barrs hit would fall under a point of emphasis the nfl has instituted for 2018. Sep 24, 2018 the nfl s roughing the passer rule is changing the game for all the wrong reasons. The new emphasis on the rule, which was put in the books back in 1995. Rule summary view official rule roughing the passer. They had a couple of really bad roughing the passer calls couple forcable contact into the ground where theres literally nothing else the defense can do. Nfl faces backlash from defensive players over new.
Roughing the passer rules apply on all passes legal or illegal thrown from behind the line of scrimmage 1229. Sep 18, 2018 the nfl rule book continues to grow every year, with new rules always added and few if any rules ever taken away. Playing rules of the national football league nfl rule book, is a foul under nfl rules and will be called by game officials 15 yard penalty. The nfl will make no rule changes regarding roughingthepasser penalties and clarified that the bodyweight provision is being enforced differently this season than it has since it was first introduced in 95, according to chris adamski of. Tracking qb hits, roughing the passer calls in nfl week 4. If a pass is thrown from beyond the line of scrimmage, unnecessary roughness may apply.
While the 2017 nfl rule book specified that a defensive player must not. Sep 28, 2018 the nfl will make no rule changes regarding roughingthepasser penalties and clarified that the bodyweight provision is being enforced differently this season than it has since it was first introduced in 95, according to chris adamski of. Nfl issues clarification on roughing the passer rule to. A radical idea for creating clarity as to roughing the passer. The new rule, which is located in rule 12, section 2, article 9 of the nfls rule book. Sep 26, 2018 former star quarterback joe theismann on why he disagrees with the nfl s new roughing the passer penalty. Roughing the passer by quarterback nfl penalty stats. A defender is allowed to take one step after the ball is thrown. The nfl tweaked language in the rule book that emphasized penalizing. And, once again, packers linebacker clay matthews is smack dab in the middle of it all but the nfl. Nfl officiating controversy wont go away the washington post. Some say these penalties are evidence of the nfl making offense even easier at the expense of defenders. Some of the big storylines have included the chiefs and rams efficient offenses, all browns games being thrillers and now drew brees becoming the alltime passing yards leader. Dan patrick talks about the recent influx of roughing the passer penalties and how officials are being instructed to enforce the rule by the nfl.
The penalty is 10 or 15 yards, depending on the league, and an automatic first down for the offense. New nfl roughing the passer rule causing more problems than. The most recent one added to the nfl rulebook is rule 7, section 2, part. Per pfts report, the nfl actually tracks missed roughing the passer calls, and newton has somehow only been the victim of three of. Rule 12 player conduct section 1 blocking, use of hands, arms, and body legal and illegal block article 1 a player of either team may block obstruct or impede an opponent at any time, provided that. Theyve just gone too far with roughing the passer calls. Sep 18, 2019 the new orleans saints, infamously hurt by a noncall in the nfc championship game, already have been involved in debates over two calls, and among other issues, a roughing the passer penalty. Everyone was worried about the new helmet rule, but the body weight call.
During the 201920 nfl season jameis winston became the first qb to ever throw 30 touchdowns and 30 interceptions. This edition of the official playing rules of the national football league contains all current rules governing the playing of professional football that are in effect for the 2019 nfl season. The nfls controversial new roughing the passer rule, explained. The nfls response to the clay matthews penalty is just. Former star quarterback joe theismann on why he disagrees with the nfls new roughing the passer penalty. Roughing the passer rules apply on all passes legal or illegal thrown from behind the line of scrimmage. The rule in question rule 12, section 2, article 9b calls for a roughing the passer penalty when a defensive player lands on a passer with. Sep 23, 2018 packers linebacker clay matthews and coach mike mccarthy couldnt believe that the team was called for roughing the passer.
The nfl rule book continues to grow every year, with new rules always added and few if any rules ever taken away. Nfl execs uncomfortable about roughing the passer calls. Many of those have involved the leagues increased emphasis on the body weight aspect of the rule. New enforcement of roughing the passer rule may have a. Sep 30, 2018 last week, talk about the nfl s roughingthepasser call dominated the league, as flags were seemingly flying left and right. In football, if roughness werent necessary, there wouldnt be a penalty called.
327 488 918 630 1336 30 1102 557 744 1527 754 270 888 1268 1048 193 715 791 413 39 550 1311 20 1419 1285 1013 329 700 694 893 132 1444 264